Ep 6: From Prohibition to Neo-Temperance With Historian Dan Malleck

January 24, 2025 01:17:21
Ep 6: From Prohibition to Neo-Temperance With Historian Dan Malleck
Drinks Insider
Ep 6: From Prohibition to Neo-Temperance With Historian Dan Malleck

Jan 24 2025 | 01:17:21

/

Hosted By

Felicity Carter

Show Notes

Prohibition didn’t begin as Prohibition. It was a bottom-up movement embraced by working people but seized on by temperance campaigners, who turned it into a disastrous social experiment that’s a byword for authoritarian overreach. Prof Dan Malleck from Brock University in Canada is a medical historian who has studied Prohibition and its fall-out and charted the rise of the contemporary neo-temperance movement.

In this special Drinks Insider episode, Dan discusses the history of the temperance movement, highlighting its moral and economic underpinnings, and compares it to the current neo-temperance movement. He critiques their selective use of research, particularly the attempt to undermine J-curve research, that associates moderate drinking with lower mortality.

This episode explores the unintended consequences of prohibitionist policies, both historically and in contemporary contexts such as Australia's tobacco control measures. The conversation does a deep dive into the question of how to balance public health concerns with individual liberty.

Other Episodes

Episode 35

September 17, 2025 00:46:42
Episode Cover

Ep 35: How Bonterra Built a New 50,000 Case Brand by Thinking Like CPG

Kate Herbert used to sell cereal and pet food at General Mills and J.M. Smucker. Now she’s in wine, where the budgets are smaller,...

Listen

Episode

September 25, 2024 01:01:33
Episode Cover

Ep 3: The Commercial Determinants of Health With Christopher Snowdown

Why are there so many anti-alcohol stories appearing in the media? One of the harshest critics of the anti-alcohol movement is Christopher Snowdon, Head...

Listen

Episode 38

October 29, 2025 00:50:31
Episode Cover

Ep. 38: Zero Sugar, 90 Points, 1 Smash Hit: The Story Behind Sunny With a Chance of Flowers

What can dog food teach you about the wine market? Heidi Scheid was walking through the supermarket in 2019 when she noticed that there...

Listen